You’re not a troll. Ignore him.
Koro if you don’t see what was the issue then you are part of the problem.
A good thing in community is also to respect the decision of moderators.
So I will explain the decision here once and only once. I really don’t believe that I have to do it.
The reason I ban the user was that he was repeating the same message three times and also staying false and misleading information about Xenko: that it was acting as a malware/spyware. Even after that fact was corrected by another post in that thread.
I don’t prevent people to have opinion but in a discussion such as “X vs Y”, repeating three times in a row that “Y is better” without any argument is similar to trolling (even if the intention of that person was not): it doesn’t give any new information, doesn’t help the original poster and is just making noise. Plus it has the capacity to start a religious war on that same subject.
For having seen this kind of behavior make perfectly fine discussion become toxic I decided to stop it as soon as possible.
So to summarize: any idea is welcome, even critics (in fact of you look at other threads you will see that we welcome critics) as long as it is faire, justified and properly arguments with facts.
That was not the case here.
8 Likes
You are right to some extent, i could post the video without comments to express Godot capabilities.
Such topics about engine vs engine will never be constructive because each will say he’s the best. Looking at other engine is good when the goal is to get inspiration.
Last time i checked Xenko it could not install.
Another things i don’t like is the install seems to be too big.
1 Like
@Roman I agree .
xenko feels like a professional engine like unreal
I loved that
I will wait for fourth release xenko 4.0
but now Godot time
I personally wouldn’t compare.
Xenko is an extremely new engine which was made open source and the community is now responsible for developing, both engine and community wise.
It is rapidly growing.
I tried both and really didn’t fall from Godot’s graphics but it’s really easy to learn how to work with it and make a game quickly.
As for Xenko, I fell in love, but it’s truly lacking many features as it is now, but that is being quickly changed.
Cheers!
2 Likes
@Kryptos well I must say you sealed the deal for me. I have been looking to make the jump from a 2 engine to a 3d engine. My finalists we’re Xenko and Godot . I must say that I was leaning pretty heavily towards Xenko… That is until I came across your words with @Roman and your subsequent ban of him. You clearly enjoy your power and like to use it. This can be seen in the language you use in this forum. The comment you made saying he can think and reflect on what he did wrong and then followed up by a rant that you don’t have to explain your self, but because we are lucky, you are gonna explain it once and only once…??? This wreaks of inflated ego from your self perceived power. Rather than ban him the first time with no explanation why not explain how Xenko doesn’t see documentation as spyware? Some folks do see it as akin to spyware so discussion was warranted. Thank you for making my decision an easy one though…I’ll be going with Godot… A community that doesn’t ban people for healthy discussion.
I suggest you read the whole conversation again.
Roman was making false claims and continued to do so even after being corrected.
If you have spent any time in any communities, you will know that if this kind of behavior is not stopped, it can lead to Holly wars that poison a whole community.
If you also had spent more than an hour here in Xenko community, you will know that we welcome critics as long as they are constructive.
It has nothing to do with ego or exercisong power or whatever your non-sensical comment meant. The role of a moderator is to make sure that discussion can continue in good faith, which was not the case here.
Final note, you do realize that this incident was more than half a year ago. If I was really the power-angry person you believe I am, don’t you think I would have banned dozen of people since then?
Edit: did you just created an account that to post that? Looking at your history (yes Discourse also keep metrics, should it be called a spyware as well?), you have spent 3 min on the forums. Which mean you didn’t even read the whole discussion or participated in any fashion in the community. And yet you were quick to judge me and call me an egocentric and power-angry person. What do you think of that behavior?
4 Likes